Andreas is the senior research professor of new testament at southeastern baptist theological seminary in wake forest, nc. Kelly,2 ceslaus spicq,3 and luke timothy johnson,4 each of whom defends the authenticity of the pastorals in his commentary on the epistles, renders extended comment on our part unnecessary. This discussion will assume pauline authorship of the pastoral epistles, although this is not critical for applying the letters to the workplace. But from all my research into this topic, the arguments. Pastoral epistles encyclopedia of the bible bible gateway. This was an established literary style as early as the 4th century bce. George knights commentary on the pastoral epistles is the best contemporary commentary on these books.
Mar 28, 2009 there are a number of helpful commentaries on the pastoral epistles, and the following are five of the best. The genuineness and authorship of the pastoral epistles. My new go to commentary on the pastoral epistles canon. Epistle simply means a literary letter which was intended to be published and read by the general public. They were always reckoned among the homologumena, as distinct from the. In his letters to timothy and titus, the apostle paul is concerned with church order, defending correct doctrine and passing on the faith. Wbc authors are all experts in their field and skillfully bring the text to meaning. Having covered galatians, pauls earliest new testament letter, we come now to his last canonical epistles 1 and 2 timothy and titus, otherwise called the pastoral epistles due to their concern with church leaders and similar topics. The three epistles1 timothy, 2 timothy, and titustraditionally ascribed to the apostle paul. The three pastoral epistles, 1 timothy, 2 timothy and titus, purport to have been written by the apostle paul before his death in the 60s of the first century. One reason scholars doubt the authenticity of the authorship claim of 2 thessalonians is a. Paul and the pastorals assign different meanings to certain words. There never was a serious doubt as to the pauline authorship of these epistles till the nineteenth century, except among a few gnostics in the second century.
There are a number of helpful commentaries on the pastoral epistles, and the following are five of the best. Bowen, this commentary offers exegetical analysis of the chronological authorship of the pastoral epistles. Modern scholarly consensus is that all three are deuteropauli. Classic commentaries and studies on the pastoral epistles 12. The epistles of the bible are the 21 books in the new testament that constitute formal letters of instruction from elders to leaders and members of the new christian church. Someone other than paul as the author of the pastoral. Mcgiffert a history of christianity in the apostolic age, 402is that the christianity of the pastoral epistles is not the christianity of. They were always reckoned among the homologumena, as distinct from the seven antilegomena, or disputed books of the new testament. The pastoral epistles and the mind of paul donald guthrie on.
The genuineness and authorship of the pastoral epistles j. The pauline letters in the christian scriptures new testament did not start out as epistles. Aug 28, 2009 donald guthries introduction to the volume, along with a helpful appendix, provides a strong defence of pauline authorship of the pastoral epistles, setting them in the distinct historical context of pauls later ministry. Mark goodacre on the accepted idea that pauls letters predate the writing of the canonical gospels. These writings include three of the new testaments 27 books, of its 260 chapters, and three of.
This series designed for the lay reader, but written by scholars allows the average reader to access the major issues surrounding the pastoral epistles, without submerging them in the technical jargon of a specialist. His earlier epistles, monumental as they are in build and weight, have their familiar unbendings. All three are letters from an old man at the close of his ministry who is concerned for his successors in the pastorate. These three books of the canon of scripture form a distinct unit known as the pastoral epistles. Porter, pauline authorship and the pastoral epistles. Attributed to pauls authorship throughout the duration of his imprisonments, bowen expounds on the variation in stylistic writing. Donald guthries introduction to the volume, along with a helpful appendix, provides a strong defence of pauline authorship of the pastoral epistles, setting them in the distinct historical context of pauls later ministry. Pastoral epistles 4 the authorship of the pastoral epistles throughout the course of the last two millennia, the books of 1 timothy, 2 timothy, and titus have been a source of guidance and direction for leaders of the church and believers everywhere.
Most scholars today conclude that saint peter was not the author of the two epistles that are attributed to him and that. The authorship of the petrine epistles first and second peter is an important question in biblical criticism, parallel to that of the authorship of the pauline epistles, since scholars have long sought to determine who were the exact authors of the new testament letters. The classic commentaries and studies on the pastoral epistles offers some of the most significant classic studies on the pastoral epistles from the latenineteenth and earlytwentiethcenturies. Nov 16, 2009 if the gnosticism addressed was an early one that was mixed with judaism, much like what we find in colossians, then an early date of authorship for the pastoral epistles is best. The term catholic was used in the sense of general or universal to distinguish them from the pauline epistles which were addressed to churches or persons. The pastoral epistles are three letters written by the apostle paul. The wbc is the bestselling multivolume commentary series in the market today. Implications for canon, bulletin for biblical research 5 1995. Oxford university press usa publishes scholarly works in all academic disciplines, bibles, music, childrens books, business books, dictionaries, reference books, journals, text books and more. Excellent for group studies, this book will serve anyone looking to deepen their. The pastoral epistles and work bible commentary theology. Of all the epistles of paul, these are the most contested.
I think paul wrote all the letters attributed to him. If the date was early, not only was it possible that paul wrote the pastorals, but a pseudonymous author was very unlikely, since a different author would not have. Lohfink argued the theology of the pastoral epistles agreed with pauls, but took this as proof someone wishing to enjoy the authority of an apostle copied the famous. The pauline epistles are the fourteen books in the new testament traditionally attributed to paul the apostle, although many dispute the anonymous epistle to the hebrews as being a pauline epistle. They used the word general because these letters were addressed to christians in general instead of a particular person or congregation like the prison epistles and the pastoral epistles. Classic commentaries and studies on the pastoral epistles. But i recognise there is a scholarly consensus that he didnt, in particular the pastoral epistles.
Our 2009 daily studies are surveying pauls life and thought through a look at both his first and final epistles. Mcgiffert a history of christianity in the apostolic age, 402is that the. Easton argued their theological notions disagreed with other pauline works, and rejected pauline authorship. External evidence is as strong as that which is present for most of the other pauline epistles with the exception of 1 corinthians and romans 3. Thirteen of the epistles were written by the apostle paul, three by the apostle john, two by. One of the general epistles is the epistle of james.
Undue stress has been laid upon divergences from previous usages. For example, with the same epistles mentioned above, b. The authorship of the pastoral epistles malcolm nicholson. Authorship very few of the critics think that the writer of 1 timothy is different from the writer of 2 timothy, and also different from the writer of titus. The pauline epistles are the fourteen books in the new testament traditionally attributed to paul the apostle, although many dispute the anonymous epistle to the hebrews as being a pauline epistle there is nearly universal consensus in modern new testament scholarship on a core group of authentic pauline epistles whose authorship is rarely. There is nearly universal consensus in modern new testament scholarship on a core group of authentic pauline epistles whose authorship is rarely. Modern scholarship casts more doubt on the authenticity of these epistles than on any of the other pauline letters. If the gnosticism addressed was an early one that was mixed with judaism, much like what we find in colossians, then an early date of authorship for the pastoral epistles is best. Pastoral epistles, paul, pseudepigraphy, canon, pauline theology in considering the status of the pastoral epistles in the new testament canon, the issue usually reduces down to that of.
An introduction to the pastoral epistles 12 timothy and. The genuineness and authorship of the pastoral epistles john daniel james on. Because of its focus on the pastorals, we are highlighting it. Pastoral epistles authorship term paper example topics. Knight, iii the pastoral epistles new international greek testament commentary, 1999. The objections to the pauline authorship of the pastorals, based upon the dissimilarity of diction in them and in ephesians, philippians and colossians, cease to exist when theory is no longer persisted in, that the nucleus of the pastoral epistles was composed during the roman imprisonment, which, according to this theory ended, not in the. The pastoral epistles comprise three books in the canonical new testament. Pauline authorship of the pastoral epistles 1 was virtually undisputed until the modern period 2. A good summary of the evidence cited on both sides can be found in e. It is not a particularly accurate description of the epistles because they are not manuals of pastoral care. As such, the letters concern the things that would be crucial for the young pastors to.
Objections to pauline authorship the general claim is that these epistles were written near the beginning of the second. The pastoral epistles include three new testament books written near the end of the apostle pauls life. In a new brill volume, anna rebecca solevag has produced a chapter that examines children in the pastorals from the perspectives of intersectionality and disability studies. However, the majority of academics now believe that the pastorals are either entirely pseudonymous, written entirely by. They are called pastoral because they are letters with instructions for pastors, congregations, and general functions within the church. Knights study on the pastoral epistles is part of the new international greek testament commentary, a series based on the ubs greek new testament, which seeks to provide thorough exegesis of the text that is sensitive to theological themes as well as to the details of the historical, linguistic, and textual context. David eastman on the three letters in the new testament known as the pastoral epistles. Pastoral epistles international standard bible encyclopedia. First and 2 timothy and titus have been known as the pastoral epistles since the early 18th cent. Arguments against pauline authorship include the following. The pastoral epistles are 1 timothy, 2 timothy, and titus.
Renowned nt scholar donald guthrie brings his expertise to the tyndale new testament commentary. The work of such distinguished students of the nt as joachim jeremias,1 j. The pastoral epistles are those letters written by paul to timothy and titus in the new testament. For a thorough discussion of this perspective on authorship, see william d. Horton, classic commentaries and studies on the pastoral epistles offers over 2,000 pages of interpretation, observations. The general epistles are books in the form of letters in the new testament. Authenticity virtually all agree the authorship of the pastorals stand together. The pastoral epistles ebook christian books, bibles. Thirteen of the epistles were written by the apostle paul, three by the apostle john, two by the apostle peter, and one each by james and jude. Introduction we now come to the final eight epistles of the new testament canon, seven of which have often been called the general or catholic epistles, though hebrews has been excluded from this description.
1171 1644 3 216 1302 500 124 399 800 1236 643 1515 1258 1013 12 387 1489 1624 318 170 846 613 1149 10 348 1400 183 571 1365 1384 1169